Florida Keys Fishing Charter Testimonials
Thousands of satisfied customers over 2 decades!
Captain Jeff has many reviews allover the web, this page automatically collects those reviews. Catch ‘Em All Sportfishing is listed on Google, Facebook, Yelp and TripAdvisor.
Thousands of customers have had an awesome time on the water with Captain Jeff Shelar and so can you. Feel free to read them and when your ready click the book now button.
Overall Rating
Captain Jeff was a really nice guy, funniest captain that has took me fishing. Would recommend him to my friends and family.
We’ve been fishing with Jeff for several years in a row. He’s so experienced and always makes sure everyone has an amazing time and catches a variety of different fish species (his good taste in music is just an added bonus). If you’re in the Keys, go spend the day with Jeff, you won’t regret it!
Our family went out on a 4-hour fishing trip and thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. It was a windy cold day in the keys and this was our highlight of the entire week. We are all pretty newbies and he was patient and good humor.
Had an awesome time and Jeff is very knowledgeable! We caught some great fish!
Captain Jeff took us out on a great 4-hour fishing excursion where we caught 6 different species of fish. We brought home 10 Yellowtail for a yummy dinner. He was patient, and had some awesome music and jokes!
Captain Jeff was AWESOME! He was on time, super nice, boat was super clean! The music was vibing, Captain Jeff had awesome jokes as well. He was so patient with all of us, explained everything and helped us catch 10+ fish! It was such a fun time!
Awesome & fun experience! The captain is enthusiastic, helpful, patient and knows all the good fishing spots! Our group was very happy with our trip 🙂
Such a great day! Captain Jeff made sure we had an amazing time out, not only ensuring we caught enough fish to feed us for a few good dinners, but also taking the time to make sure we had the best experience ever! He knows what he's doing, and has the patience to teach non-experienced fishers what to do so everyone has fun!
We’ve used Captain Jeff for the past 15 years and he has not disappointed us yet. We have caught a wide variety of fish and he always provides a solid playlist 🤘
Jeff is a great captain, and our experience was unreal. Easy 5/5 with no complaints. Definitely would recommend to anyone!
Captain Jeff is fantastic! We’ve gone twice with him and catch plenty of fish each time. Highly recommended!
Fourth year in a row fishing with Captain Jeff always puts us on fish and always likes to joke and have a good time. Makes sure he takes extra time to teach me how to do things the right way 👍👍
Hands down one of the best fishing trips we’ve ever been on! Captain Jeff with Catch Em’ All Sportfishing was awesome—professional, laid-back, and incredibly knowledgeable. He put us on the fish and kept the trip fun the entire time. If you want a captain who knows the waters, works hard to make sure you catch fish, and truly enjoys what he does, Captain Jeff is your guy.
Super nice guy, made sure we got enough fish for dinner and also helped my boyfriend catch a big fish for fun! Definitely recommend, super helpful to make sure everyone’s catching fish, great with people! We did a 6 hour and caught a lot!
We had an awesome experience with captain Jeff! Despite some rough weather, he went out of his way to accommodate us and make the most of a short trip. We still caught a lot of fish, and he went above and beyond to help a young kid land a shark—an experience that absolutely made the trip! We also caught some big Cobia so we had plenty of fish to take home and eat. His effort saved our fishing vacation when the weather wasn’t cooperating. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a great guide who genuinely cares about catching fish for his clients!
