Fuel Is Included in ALL trip prices.
No fuel surcharges!
View Rates
(305) 481.4568
Winner of the TripAdvisor Travelers’ Choice Award for 12 years!
jnsshelar@att.net

Reviews

Florida Keys Fishing Charter Testimonials

yelptripadvisorgoogleOverall Rating
4.9
Based on 754 Reviews
google
Wyatt Schlueter
July 2, 2026

Had a great time, caught some nice fish and most importantly got a ton of fish for dinner.

google
Devin Lausch
July 1, 2026

Great day of fishing with Captain Jeff and mate Dylan! We caught a lot of fish and the biggest two fish our family has ever caught. What I appreciated most was that he kept his boat clean and tidy. Captain Jeff was very fun and professional. We would definitely fish with him again! Great for a families!

google
Jameson Lausch
July 1, 2026

It was a wonderful experience fishing with Captain Jeff and his son, Dylan. They are experts at their craft and knew where to go on the water to find the best catch while making the ride, relaxing, fun, and clean. As an added bonus the tunes were awesome! Our family of five highly recommends booking with Catch ‘Em All Sport Fishing.

google
Karen Sanford
June 17, 2026

Catch Em All with Jeff and Dillon was an absolute BEST day of fishing. They were professional, respectful, and knew exactly the in and outs of getting us on some fish. We loved our off shore experience and getting to make memories together. The boat was a perfect size to move around and space to fish. We’ll be back and get another great day of fishing on the books. Keep it reeling

google
Ella Sanford
June 17, 2026

We had an awesome time on this deep sea fishing trip! The crew was friendly, knowledgeable, and made sure everyone had a great experience. We caught plenty of fish and had a lot of fun out on the water. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a fun day of fishing!

google
Logan Sanford
June 17, 2026

Great time on the boat catching mahi mahi!!

google
Collin Rowe
June 15, 2026

Easily the best and most rewarding fishing charter i’ve ever been on! Jeff the captain is super knowledgeable and will put you right on top of fish. We sat on spots for hours pulling up upwards of 20 mahi! Nobody better in marathon to go out with if you want to seriously catch trophy fish!

google
Braydon Taylor
June 15, 2026

We had a great time. Jeff and Dillon were super nice and helpful the entire trip. They made sure we caught fish and fun doing so. Highly recommend using them and we will be in contact with them again in the future. Thanks guys, from KCMO crew we had a blast!

google
Johnnie Campbell
June 9, 2026

Captain Jeff did a great job. He was very knowledgeable, and laid back.This was our first time fishing offshore and he was very patient teaching us the techniques. We had a great time catching Mahi Mahi. I would highly recommend going on a trip with him.

google
Aaron Brassfield
June 4, 2026

For a graduation gift, we got my nephew a tarpon fishing trip. Captain Jeff, Captain Jill, and Dillan worked hard to help get him his bucket list fish, even when the weather was being problematic…But they kept working options. My nephew even said they weren’t just focused on getting us on fish, but the full experience. We will always remember the trip and how everyone made him feel on a special day. Forever grateful and definitely recommend them.

google
Drew Lippert
April 29, 2026

Had a great time with Jeff. He was very knowledgable and shared lots if tips. Deck lady Sara was equally knowledgable and friendly. We caught 5 Mahi Mahi keepers. Definitely the charter boat to use in Marathon.

google
charlie cerny
April 29, 2026

Had a fabulous day with Capt Jeff and Sarah. Jeff put us Mahi unlike a lot of other boats. 5 beauties. Thanks, look forward to next time.

google
Rebecca Jones
April 26, 2026

Awesome trip! Put us on Mahi Mahi our bucket list trip! Hope to see you again Jeff

google
Cameron Place
April 16, 2026

Captain Jeff is awesome. Caught some great yellowfin and nice Amberjack. Got some rock n roll lessons along the way as well. Highly recommend.

google
riley timmins
April 15, 2026

This was our first time to the Florida Keys and we were very excited to get out on a fishing trip with our kids. The weather turned bad and were unable to get out. After some discussion with Captain Jeff, letting him know we were up for anything, he made a plan to get us on some fish even with the wind. Weather was still tough, but the kids rallied and they had a blast catching a bunch of blue runners. After a couple hours, Captain Jeff set us up for sharks. Which was unexpected and exciting! We hooked into one and it was a fight I wasn’t ready for! Captain Jeff went above and beyond to deliver an exciting and memorable trip for our family. We definitely will fish with him again next time we travel to the Keys!

google
Kyle Johnson
April 15, 2026

Great time, each person caught and landed multiple fish ( the ones we lost were fun fights as well ).

google
Jennifer Johnson
April 15, 2026

We all had a great time. Jeff was very knowledgeable and helped us every step of the way.

google
mac mikalunas
April 7, 2026

Captain Jeff is awesome and knows what he is doing, We wanted to go after different species of fish and he told us what was biting and we went to get what he suggested, I am happy he did because the water way out was still cold and the Tuna and Mahi were not up on the cooler water yet, I had a great time and would definitely recommend.

google
james boyter
April 2, 2026

Fantastic time with captain Jeff!

google
Ciera Gary
April 2, 2026

Captain Jeff put us on fish for dinner and fish for fun! We had a great day! Would definitely come back and fish with Jeff again!